Will,
Moral ambitions in the absence of evidence are often the worst crimes that mankind commits. It’s certainly true of the 100M dead due to leftism and communism over the past era.
1) If the poor people who are poor because they lack the neoteny, self regulation, intelligence, resulting in unfavorable family structure, traditions, norms, and values, move into communities with better behaved and more able people, the better people will flee. They always have in every civilization and they always will because it’s rational self interest.
2) Western civ is the highest investment polity (highest psychological and emotional cost) in prosocial norms the world has ever constructed, and association with those incapable of equal prosocial norms only raises the costs and lowers the outcome of less evolved and less developed peoples, and as such those capable of higher investment parenting in suppression of impulsivity, extension of time preference (delay of gratification), and investment in the capacity for individual responsibility will flee those who raise the cost of that investment.
2) The history of ‘white flight’ (jewish flight, now asian flight), is well documented. You can’t change it. It’ll never change. It’s rational self interest.
3) Additionally, the history of “Proximity creates hostility” is well documented. It’s one thing if there is no more than 1SD of variation among an ethnic group, but if an ethnic group exceeds 1SD on the average then the lower SD group will always suffer lower status, lower achievement, lower performance, and lower standards of living.
4) Additionally, destruction of trust and destruction of civil institutions resulting in “bowling alone” is well documented.
5) When incompatible groups are force into competition resulting in inequality of outcomes the superior group will seek institutional defense against the costs of the inferior group, and the inferior group will seek institutional offense against the inequality caused by their proximity to the superior group.
6) In case you haven’t been scientifically literate since 1999, the plasticity of humans, meaning the nature nurture debate has been settled, it’s 70-80% nature and 20-30% idiosyncratic experience (randomness). Even if we try, all statistically improvements disappear by adulthood. IQ was settled before 2000. Sex differences were settled by 2012. Race differences were settled by 2018. These are immutable differences in neotenic, sexual, and regional development as mankind spread across the world.
These differences are not only correlative but causally explained behaviors obvious to every single person who has studied any depth of genetics, cognitive science, behavioral economics, political economy, and those few of us who work in comparative group evolutionary strategies.
All you are doing will, is confirming wishful cognitive biases that are easily explained, just as pseudoscientists (the marxist sequence) and theologians (the abrahamic sequence) and the many shaman have done for millennia.
What you don’t understand is that by lying intentionally or by indirectly lying because of a failure of due diligence, and in support of your own cognitive bias combined with false feedback provided by attention seeking, is that you are justifying the end of participatory government, and in particular the participation of women and the underclasses by demonstrating you are willing to profit from the misleading of victims of your deception
The solution is to admit that copying the Russians during the civil rights era, destroyed the black family, ended the developing black middle and upper middle classes, black institutions, and most importantly the emergent black intellectual class.
The only solution is self determination, wherein people choose who they want to live with and who they do not. In other words, separation: the federation of many small nation states of europe (at least prior to the french attempt at dominating europe), is the optimum political order.
Oddly the europeans tried (and are failing) at creating an america of europe at the same time the centralization of america in response to the civil war is being overthrown by trying to conflate continental economic and strategic needs for uniformity, with the regional and local needs for social variation.
What Im telling you is that you’re just making things worse. You’re not alone. The academy and the bureaucracy who are equally ignorant and inexperience in the organization, management, and governance of people of any scale other than the classroom or department, are doing the same.
And it’s ending.
And within a decade it will end tragically.
And it will be all your (collective) fault.
“May God save us from well meaning fools.”
Cheers
Reply addressees: @whstancil