–“What was the reasoning that led to opening european and american borders to immigrants?”–
Answer:
Economic Exploitation, Political Manipulation, Demographic manipulation, and Ideological Globalism:
Economic Exploitation:
Cheap Labor: Rather than addressing labor shortages out of necessity for growth, immigration might have been encouraged to keep wages low and profits high by exploiting immigrants who were often willing to work for less under harsh conditions. This perspective sees immigration policies as a means to keep the workforce compliant and underpaid.
Depression of Local Wages: Immigrants could also be seen as competitors for jobs, potentially driving down wages for everyone, which benefits employers more than the economy as a whole.
Political Manipulation:
Vote-Bank Politics: Political entities might have seen immigrants as future voters who could be swayed by parties or politicians offering them rights or support, thus using immigration as a tool for political gain rather than for humanitarian or economic integration.
Refugee Policies as Political Statements: Accepting refugees could be interpreted as a way for countries to score political points on the global stage, demonstrating moral superiority or commitment to certain ideological battles, rather than a genuine effort to help those in need.
Demographic Manipulation:
Cultural Dilution: From a pessimistic viewpoint, opening borders could be seen as a strategy to dilute or change the cultural, ethnic, or racial makeup of a nation, potentially leading to social tensions or loss of national identity.
Cultural and Ideological Conflicts:
Selective Integration: While nations might celebrate being built by immigrants, there’s a darker side where certain groups might not be welcomed as warmly, leading to selective immigration where only those who can quickly assimilate or are from ‘preferred’ backgrounds are encouraged.
Globalization’s Dark Side:
Economic Dumping Ground: Countries might open their borders not out of benevolence but because they see an opportunity to offload surplus population from other countries, essentially treating immigration as a way to manage global population distribution without addressing root causes like conflict, poverty, or environmental degradation.
Neocolonialism: Immigration could also be viewed as a new form of colonialism where labor is imported from less developed countries to serve the economic interests of developed nations, continuing a cycle of dependency and exploitation.
This view frames immigration policies as potentially self-serving, focusing on the negatives like exploitation, cultural erosion, and political manipulation, rather than the positive aspects of cultural enrichment, economic growth, and humanitarian aid.