Curt Doolittle

Category: Natural Law and Reciprocity

  • Morality = Reciprocity

    Morality = Reciprocity. https://propertarianism.com/2019/09/25/morality-reciprocity/

    Source date (UTC): 2019-09-25 15:24:09 UTC

    Original post: https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1176880072130781184

  • Morality = Reciprocity.

    Morality = Reciprocity. And it has to be. Moral norms are members of a portfolio (network) that may be reciprocal or not. Moral intuitions vary by the individual’s reproductive balance of reciprocity vs proportionality in the given set of moral norms. So whenever speaking of ‘morality’ which thing are you talking about? Ideal knowable (reciprocity). Ideal unknowable (anything not immoral and therefore irreciprocal is moral. What we mean is, what’s good? Not what’s moral?) Moral Norm (evolved market for prohibitions), Moral intuition (your bias given your reproductive and survival demands) – in other words, your tolerance for proportionality. Curt Doolittle

  • Morality = Reciprocity.

    Morality = Reciprocity. And it has to be. Moral norms are members of a portfolio (network) that may be reciprocal or not. Moral intuitions vary by the individual’s reproductive balance of reciprocity vs proportionality in the given set of moral norms. So whenever speaking of ‘morality’ which thing are you talking about? Ideal knowable (reciprocity). Ideal unknowable (anything not immoral and therefore irreciprocal is moral. What we mean is, what’s good? Not what’s moral?) Moral Norm (evolved market for prohibitions), Moral intuition (your bias given your reproductive and survival demands) – in other words, your tolerance for proportionality. Curt Doolittle

  • “Can you relate in-group vs out-group to morality = reciprocity ?”—Scott Clare

    —“Can you relate in-group vs out-group to morality = reciprocity ?”—Scott Claremont

    Morality = Rules of cooperation

    INGROUP VS OUTGROUP
    1. Ingroup,
    2. outgroup
    … a. outgroup trade,… https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=472302760033286&id=100017606988153

    Source date (UTC): 2019-09-25 14:21:08 UTC

    Original post: https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1176864215749091336

  • “Can you relate in-group vs out-group to morality = reciprocity ?”—Scott Clare

    —“Can you relate in-group vs out-group to morality = reciprocity ?”—Scott Claremont

    Morality = Rules of cooperation

    INGROUP VS OUTGROUP

    1. Ingroup,

    2. outgroup

    … a. outgroup trade,

    … b. outgroup boycott,

    … c. outgroup competitor,

    … d. outgroup parasite

    … e. outgroup predator

    Ingroup by definition = cooperation (moral)

    Ingroup always requires reciprocity.

    Ingroup oten requires investment (risk)

    Ingroup often requires insurance

    Ingroup may require subsidy.

    Outgroup by definition only requires utility.

    Outgroup may or may not require reciprocity

    Outgroup does not require investment (risk)

    Outgroup does not demand insurance

    Outgroup does not require subsidy.

    Outgroup non-cooperation is disutilitarian

    Outgroup non-cooperation does not require reciprocity

    Outgroup non-cooperation does not require investment

    Outgroup non-cooperation does not require insurance

    Outgroup non-cooperation does not require subsidy

    Outgroup enemy is harmful

    Outgroup enemy requires irreciprocity

    Outgroup enemy requires costs to impose costs

    Outgroup enemy requires destruction of their insurance

    Outgroup enemy requires destruction of their subsidies

    Lesson: you can’t use one rule for scale.

    Humans are monkeys that want to imitate or follow a single pre-cognitive intuitions rather than think (remember or reason).

    But spectra require disambiguation and thought.

    There are no points(ideal types) only lines (spectra). 😉

    Source date (UTC): 2019-09-25 10:20:00 UTC

  • photos_and_videos/PropertarianQuotes_7nHR3JAXZw/71841121_116841156380713_1566820

    photos_and_videos/PropertarianQuotes_7nHR3JAXZw/71841121_116841156380713_156682017570816000_o_116841153047380.jpg

    Source date (UTC): 2019-09-25 06:59:00 UTC

  • photos_and_videos/PropertarianQuotes_7nHR3JAXZw/71250064_116841069714055_2136081

    photos_and_videos/PropertarianQuotes_7nHR3JAXZw/71250064_116841069714055_213608115407421440_o_116841066380722.jpg

    Source date (UTC): 2019-09-25 06:59:00 UTC

  • photos_and_videos/PropertarianQuotes_7nHR3JAXZw/70764844_116841136380715_2825453

    photos_and_videos/PropertarianQuotes_7nHR3JAXZw/70764844_116841136380715_2825453023176687616_o_116841123047383.jpg

    Source date (UTC): 2019-09-25 06:59:00 UTC

  • photos_and_videos/PropertarianQuotes_7nHR3JAXZw/71389712_116841243047371_7221919

    photos_and_videos/PropertarianQuotes_7nHR3JAXZw/71389712_116841243047371_7221919428697391104_o_116841233047372.jpg

    Source date (UTC): 2019-09-25 06:59:00 UTC

  • photos_and_videos/PropertarianQuotes_7nHR3JAXZw/70688219_116841289714033_3676837

    photos_and_videos/PropertarianQuotes_7nHR3JAXZw/70688219_116841289714033_3676837260617056256_o_116841279714034.jpg

    Source date (UTC): 2019-09-25 06:59:00 UTC