all commons are redistribution. The question is whether the comons that we contribute to create either hazards, perverse incentives, and free-riding. There has been an organized effort for the beter part of a century, to support rather than avoid free riding, and penalize the middle class to fund reproduction by the lower classes.
Redistribution is probably EARNED if you adhere to manners, ethics, morals and laws – albiet the argument is too complex for this post. If you do not adhere of manners, ethics morals and laws, it is very hard to argue that you have earned any form of redistribution.