RESPONSE 😉 GC—“Monotheism won for many reasons, among them, because it coales

RESPONSE 😉

GC—“Monotheism won for many reasons, among them, because it coalesces a worldview into the univocity of truth, enabling universal dialogue. This also set the stage for science, as one truth enables interpersonal decidability via argument.”—

CD: Monotheism always and everywhere was imposed by violence. It did not win. It was imposed. The jews chose it to impose on their own, everyone else other than slaves who wanted allies in the absence of kin, had it imposed upon them. Diversity (mobile labor) generates demand for association by shared ambition.

The only value of monotheism, is the one created by its first imposer: to undermine the established aristocracy. There is only one reason for globalism: to do the same.

The only people who are equal are the poor and the slaves. The rest of us live in a set of competing hierarchies (markets for power), and in western civilization we even have different disciplinary languages for those powers (literature and philosophy, scripture and myth, and law and science.)

GC—“(This strategy has been defected on by pseudoscience boas /psychoanalysis/ critique /frankfurt/Derrida but it worked mostly well before that, the defector class has adapted well, ergo me saying Derrida was the most evil person in history. He split defection into pieces small enough for NPCs to implement, while also coopting the affective modalities of the female half of our species. He effectively generated the conditions for a borg-mob of evil, whilst at the same time delegitimizing speech as a dispute resolution and truth acquision mechanism. I am aware of no bigger evil in history. He did this knowingly (although he didn’t know about the Gulag Archipelago which arrived to him 3 years after his anus mirabilis 1967) Derrida was no ordinary monster!)”—

Agreed.

GC—“Before the evolution of pseudoscience as a defection strategy in academia, and its diaspora as of WWII the idea of one truth, inherited from the large powerful gods necessary to keep low density pastorial populations in check, helped the birth of science.”—

This is simply counter to all the evidence since science evolved where the chruch had the least influence, commerce and law had the greatest influence, and science is merely an extension of the warranty of due diligence in law and contract to testimony about the world we live in.

GC–“Four of the ten commandments (the ones you never hear about) have a coordination/detection of invaders function. To know if someone is or not a participant in your rule-equelibrium requires costly and constant testing. This cost pays off, or religions would not have evolved and taken over populations.”—

The ten commandments merely list property rights. “There are no law but these, you can knock off anyone who disagrees, and here are the things you can’t steal or even think of stealing”. Religion is the only way to unify tribal peoples of pastoralists for whom theft and deceit are honoralbe ways of life, and a man’s job is to hunt, steal, seek rents, on behalf of his family. By suppresing that theft between members he sought to unify the familialsm and tribalism in opposition to the powerful peoples that they could not resist by any other means other than cultural resistance.

GC—“The reduction in religious sentiment that followed the spreading of pseudoscience, the mass media propagation of deceipt and lying, and female suffrage spiraled into a system where media and state unite at an equelibrium that sucks in genes from patriarchal stable systems, while spreading memes that destabilize them. Genetic sinks are memetic sources, and vice versa.—

Agreed.

GC—“The less religion, the less univocity of truth. Since most people are unable to tell pseudoscience from science, they succumb to lies, eventually opening borders or establishing ochlocracies (mob rule), which pave the way to hell (barbarism).”—

Religion does not offer truth it offers a protocol of decidabilty that limits conflict between peoples of low trust in high density whoare not kin. Advanced societies produce classes with specialzed grammars and vocabularies. Religious (Semitic) societies do not. They impose monotheism (monopoly) and that monopoly limits competition.

The fact that we use the word ‘true’ for decidable is a hideous habit that was the product of exposure to and victimization by semitic monotheism (monopoly).

GC—“Most people don’t have the time, competence, or interest to be able to think of all this. Religion evolved as a stabilizer of human psychology to act in ways that are favourable to the group, and that are favourable to the individual in longer timespans, and that are favourable to an individual’s genes in even longer timespans.—

—It is a compression algorithm to run primates in a community. Its complexity cannot be overstated. Many of the functional items are unknown and unknowable, we don’t know which details worked why, anymore than we knew which details of DNA replication are or not essential for our continuity when it was discovered.—

—Culture>Religion>Nation>Tribe rules>Familiy rules>Patriarchal sovereignty within families>Intertemporal consistency of the individual>Mood consistency and regulation>Emotional control>Cognitive control> Neural netwok coordination>Neuronal health>Cellullar health>DNA replication machinery correction mechanisms>DNA replication machinery>DNA structure>Molecular shape>mycrophisics—

—“These nomological layers organize, top down and bottom up, how we function. To deny the evolution and function of those we have no conscious access to is arrogant, and to presume to understand those so tiny our microscopes can’t see, or so long in time our lifetimes cannot absorb, is wrong. We are not the correct type of pattern recognition system for the task. If you only read one page of a book, you should not judge whether to drop the book or not. Likewise with microcosmic DNA replication, and macrocosmic Deity and ritual and metaphor evolution.”—

Imprecise but agreed.

—“Christianity is the most complete religion because it needed to confront the most complex challenges: A smart population in a landmass with navigable rivers, oceans, and plains enabling different civilizations, and barbarians, to show up, sometimes openly, sometimes in disguise. High trust individualists not marrying their cousins and submitting to rule of law. Systems to bring individuals back into agency when they fall into temptation or sin. Marketing chastity as “sacred” thereby increasing the market value of sexual access, creating a cold war competition for monogamous access of the best mates in the gene pool, and incentivizing males to produce far more for the community than subsistence or short term mating typical of forests would require.”—

Ack. The most complete system of decidability is Literature, biography, history, law/economics/accounting, the sciences, math/logics, and the most market means of communicating them is through fairy tales, myths, legends, heroic tales, and histories, and the most effective means of reinforcing them is through debts (sacrifice rituals) in ‘safe’ (status neutral) surroundings.

We can train people to model a dream world, a literary world, an historical world, an active world, or an ideal (mathematical) world. We confuse the fact (often) that one way is better than all ways, or that the easiest way to dupe (suggest to people) and bypass their reason is using the suspension of disbelief, and the suggestibility that they fall into under sympathetic responses to narratives. Evidence is that ratio-scientifially trained minds are optimum. The problem isn’t mythos or living in your imagination, but the network of trust of participating in and feeling safe within an existental social order. That is what we ruined. We ruined our social order because we let the left do it.

—“The benefits of religion are so many, and so complex, we 2018 people have only begun to grasp them. We let God fall about 100 years ago. 1 Million have died per year since. It is time to reconsider our arrogance. It is not time to arrogantly try again.”—

The benefits of education are demonstrable, the difference is do you resort to a monopoly because you are not sufficiently competent to preserve the grammar(repetition), logic (internal dialog), and rhetoric(external argument) in the various grammars of calculation: physics, chemistry, biology, ecology, economy/accounting, law, logic/ mathematics, testimony, narration, literature? And then graceful failure on that scale to suit our abilities?

GC—“True, atheism works in Ishtmuses and Islands and places with really hard to cross borders and only one race since trust has a racial in-group component (Aus,JP, Koreas, China). Where there is no strong evolutionary pressure against barbarians, invaders, and defectors, high variance psychological programming systems can thrive.”—

Atheism is a misnomer. One always requires a model of the universe to operate by. The question is which GRAMMAR (rules of continuous disambiguation resulting in the ability to make comparisons and deductions), does one use to do so? One that is false (occult), one that is sophist(philosophy), one that is existential (law and economics) or one that is pure measurements (science and mathematics)?

The choice is not geography or competition but DEMOGRAPHIC ABILITY AND CAPITAL SUFFICIENT TO INVEST IN INTERGENERATIONAL TRAINING.

GC—“But our world in a digitized and globalized era is not similar to an island. “—

It’s the opposite. We all live in a giant digital city with no one more than speed of light away.

GC—“Just the opposite. It is more similar to the European land in which Christianity evolved, with threats from Islam, uprisings from minorities and mob rules, and the constant need to use costly signalling to detect who is or not “one of us” by going to church, proclaiming belief in one God, holding chastity sacred, marrying publically and monogamously, claiming belief in an afterlife that justifies going to war and self defense, and many other features that have made Europe, and the Hajnal line people what they are. A vote against Christianity is a vote for the nearest patriarchal religion with the morale to invade.”—

Religion isn’t necessary. Violent uprising and war is necessary. Why lie to people when the problem is one of truth: this doesn’t work and can’t work.

GC–“Christianity evolved to deal with the circumstance that all nations, races, and peoples have to deal with in a globalized open world. It has mob-rule preventing mechanisms (The Scapegoating Mechanism) which are paramount in the digital era against third wave feminism and adversarial reputational attacks.”—

Christianity evolved to resist the roman empire as a system of insurrection just as the abrahamic religions all evolved to do. Judaism intellectual insurrection, christianity political insurrection, and islam military insurrection, and together they destroyed every great civilization of the ancient world and created the abrahamic dark ages.

GC—“Whether Christianity is sufficient to save the West, I am not sure. But I’m fairly confident it is necessary. Mormonism has to be considered due to its resilience to mob-rule, media feminism, etc… whilst keeping a births per woman rate of staggering 3.4, higher than European Muslims.”—

Christianity contiains a very simple premise that is purely scientific in content:

“I am a christian if I have adopted the teaching of christianity: 1) the eradication of hatred from the human heart. 2) the extension of kinship love to non-kin. 3) the extension of exhaustive forgiveness before punishment, enserfment, enslavement, death, or war. As far as I know, this is all that is required of me to be a Christian.”

That’s it. It happens to be the optimum prisoner’s dilemma strategy which is why commerce and prosperity follow christianity. There is nothing in that set of three rules that cannot be taught to every child.

GC—“To ignore the evolutionary structure that gave us the Hajnal line people, who created 80% of all that matters in the world, while taming 2 billion people, is naive thinking from the void.”—

To make a justification for that which gave us the dark ages and the destruction of those of civilizations of the ancient world, and the genetic devolution of their peoples into the current state, rather than keeping pace with the northern european and east asian, is simply an attempt to resurrect the past because one has failed to find a solution to the conditions of the time.

There is only one religion of Western Civilization and Alexander, Aristotle, and Zeno are Its Prophets.

all else is not.