“Are all nationalist movements unpatriotic? Are you alleging all nationalism to

—“Are all nationalist movements unpatriotic? Are you alleging all nationalism to be right wing?”—

Let’s ask the question empirically.

Patriotic can refer to nation or state. It’s an ambiguous term.

Define left wing?

have left wing movements been nationalistic or universalist?

what can we learn from the motives of the left wing movements?

what reproductive strategy does left wing movement?

I would classify my work as left wing nationalist. (which acknowledging bothers me). I’m all for highly redistributive nationalism. I mean, that’s national socialism really.

You can try to solve the class problem vertically (nationalism) or horizontally (universalism). but the result is that nationalism produces evolution, and universalism produces devolution. And there is no way around it.