ARISTOCRACY – WE HAD IT RIGHT ALL ALONG
What other scientific evidence of good discipline, good judgement, good parenting, is there than three successive generations of family success?
When one has wealth and status then what achievements can one reach for? Culture. Arts. Civics.
We had it right for most of our history. In an effort to steal control from a reluctant aristocracy dependent upon the productivity of land, we invented a number of lies: equality the most damaging of them.
Had membership in our house of aristocracy depended entirely upon demonstrated economic merit for three generations rather than the loyalty of titled heredity, we could have survived the transition from the productivity of land to the productivity of manufacturing, finance and trade.
Had we created a house of proletarians rather than surrendering the house of common land owners to the mass of rent-seekers, so that the natural division of the classes could cooperate via exchange between those houses, we could have survived their introduction into both the economy and the polity.
Women, who in every walk of life prefer to exercise care taking, would control the house of the proletarians. Men the house of commons and lords. And the competition provided by the church would have been replaced by the lowest house as a means of resistance against exploitation.
Instead we adopted simple majority rule, thereby destroying thousands of years of the principle difference between the west and the rest: the balance of powers and the necessity for forcing a compromise between different interests in the absence of authority, given the assumption of individual sovereignty as the common good, versus an abstract unknowable concept of the common good involuntarily prosecuted upon the public.
That was our mistake. We had everything else right.
It may be too late to correct it. But the first step in fixing a problem is understanding the cause of it.
We had it right all along.
We did it. And only we did it. No other civilizations managed it.
Property = Sovereignty = Balance of Powers.
I have no problem being ruled by the best of each class.
I do have a problem being ruled by the worst of each class.
Source date (UTC): 2014-02-06 06:07:00 UTC