First, what part of rotation of elites from the middle to the top has you confus

First, what part of rotation of elites from the middle to the top has you confused? Secondly why do you think europeans evolved during the age of bronze, horse, and wheel, developed contractualism testimonail truth and sacredness of oath, resulting in rule of law and participatory government: ’cause they all had weapons’. Why do you think the age of revolutions occurred? ’cause guns’.
I mean, the IRA won, the latin communists won, the chinese communists won, the russian communists won, for all intents and purposes the muslim fundamentalists have won, the french revolution won. Sure the american and english conflicts were civil wars, so yes. But revolutionary was and civil was are two different things.

Reply addressees: @spaceangelvoice