Q:–“Do you think Elon should be totally ignored and not rebutted?”– I think ra

Q:–“Do you think Elon should be totally ignored and not rebutted?”–

I think rational debate in matters of public import is always good. I think the problem is due to asymmetric knowledge and incentives. And that we must find a solution despite the resulting variation. The only way to do that is open debate. Thankfully Elon created X so that we can finally have those debates again.

I think we all have a balance scale in our minds.
We each have a collection of weights we put on each side – the case for and against.
Our understanding and our interests determine those weights – and they vary, often quite a bit.
I think elon is correct about the top .01% of scientific and technical talent.
I think my list of recommendations is correct (see below).
I think we should aggressively deport everyone and anyone who won’t ‘buy in’ meaning full integration.
I think some groups cannot fully integrate: islamists, and that said, look at the damage done by the jews.
I am concerned some other groups can but the demographic distribution is a burden not a contribution (race issues).
I am more concerned about white rates of reproduction.
I am most concerned about he decline in average IQ because that determines EVERYTHING.

Reposting:
THE ANSWER TO THE H1B DEBATE?
(a) US colleges are selecting against white males.
(b) US colleges are selecting in favor of foreigners b/c $.
(c) The IQ distribution in China means that with a much larger population they will produce as many +130 as the USA and Europe combined.
(d) The IQ distribution in India means that while they produce around the same total +130, they are more likely to pursue USA jobs given the asymmetry of rewards.
(e) Net is that we (the west) do not produce enough +130 to compete in science and tech without SUPPLEMENTING our +130 with theirs.
(f) Policy must be:
– i) to exhaust the US supply before including foreign students in colleges and universities,
– ii) and Visa must be limited to top talent,
– iii) and birthright citizenship and chain migration must be prohibited.

As in all things demographics drive everything. That’s my understanding of the data.

Thanks
CD

Reply addressees: @Anarchrist5 @BuzzPatterson @elonmusk @X