NO TRUMP IS NOT A RAPIST. (AND “WOMEN SHOULDN’T BE BELIEVED”)
Donald Trump has not been convicted of rape in a criminal court. However, there has been confusion or misrepresentation regarding this topic stemming from various legal proceedings.
The jury voted for sympathy, not based on criminal evidence.
“The jury’s decision to find in favor of Carroll for sexual abuse and defamation rather than rape was possibly influenced by the legal definitions they were given. They might have felt her account was convincing for sexual abuse (which includes any non-consensual sexual contact) but not for rape under the narrow legal definition (which requires penile penetration) they were instructed to use.”
E. Jean Carroll’s Civil Case: In May 2023, a jury in a civil case found Trump liable for sexually abusing and defaming E. Jean Carroll but not liable for rape under New York’s legal definition which requires penile penetration[[24][20][17][15][14][13][8][5][4][3][1][0]].
Despite the jury’s verdict, Judge Lewis A. Kaplan later clarified that based on the common understanding of the term, Trump’s actions constituted rape, as he was found to have forcibly penetrated Carroll with his fingers[[11][8][5][0]].
Public Perception and Misinformation:
The misunderstanding likely arises from:
Misinterpretation or oversimplification of legal outcomes in civil cases versus criminal convictions.
Media coverage and social media discussions which might not always distinguish between civil liability for sexual abuse and criminal conviction for rape.
Statements from some individuals or media outlets that might blur the line between legal definitions and public understanding of sexual assault terms.
Allegations and Legal Actions: Numerous women have accused Trump of sexual misconduct over the years, but these allegations have not resulted in criminal rape convictions. For instance, Jill Harth accused him of attempted rape, but the lawsuit was settled outside of court[[6][2]]. There have been other allegations, but none have led to a criminal conviction for rape.
The idea that Trump has been convicted of rape might stem from confusion over the legal terminology used in civil cases, public discourse on social media, and possibly from the political rhetoric surrounding these legal battles.
Remember, “conviction” refers specifically to a finding of guilt in a criminal case, which has not occurred in relation to rape charges against Trump.
Reply addressees: @Ineedtime8 @RichardDawkins
Source date (UTC): 2024-11-13 00:27:35 UTC
Original post: https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1856494079242317825
Replying to: https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1856492585721721205
Leave a Reply